John Liu Campaign Reimbursed Donors With Print Ads
NEW YORK—As a way of saying “thank you,” City Comptroller John Liu’s 2013 mayoral campaign was purchasing print ads for companies that donated to them.
Liu’s former treasurer, Jia (Jenny) Hou, and a fundraiser, Xing Wu (Oliver) Pan, were found guilty on May 2 by a grand jury in Manhattan’s southern district federal courthouse for attempting to defraud New York City by using straw donors to illegally obtain public matching funds. For every $1 in qualifying funds, a candidate can apply for an additional $6 from the city under a matching funds program.
One of Liu’s aides, Sharon Lee, admitted before court during the trial that the John Liu campaign was purchasing ads in Chinese newspapers for companies that donated. Lee said this was done “to thank them.”
During the trial, witnesses from Chinese businesses confirmed they received print ads from Liu’s campaign after donating, and email records backed up the claims.
In a September 8, 2011, email shown to the court, Hou told a businessman that the Liu campaign would be publishing ads for his company in all major Chinese newspapers.
The businessman, Yi-Lang (Alex) Lu, who was the special assistant to the President of W&L Group Construction Inc, Wuang Meng (Thomas) Hua, admitted in court that he recruited straw donors for Liu’s campaign on behalf of W&L. He raised $15,200 for Liu, and made the campaign eligible for an additional $19,950 in public matching funds.
The scheme to reimburse businesses with print ads fits in with a discussion between Pan and an undercover FBI agent, which was captured on July 27, 2011, by a hidden video camera.
Pan tells the agent that Liu called him to make a strategy to help raise four or five million dollars for his mayoral campaign.
“I say, ‘John, actually quite easy, people donate, we give something in return,’” Pan says in a transcript.